I’ve written about Reviewer 3 before (here, here, here, and here). Somehow the third reviewer has come to embody the capriciousness (and sometimes meanness) of the anonymous peer review process. Note that I believe in the peer review process, but am a realist about what it means and what it accomplishes. It doesn’t mean that every paper passing peer review is perfect and it doesn’t mean that every peer reviewer is doing a great job of reviewing.
When I’m a reviewer I see the peer review process through the lens of the line from Spiderman (Stan Lee), “with great power comes great responsibility”. I strive to put as much effort in to each paper I review as I would expect and want from the reviewers who review my papers. Sometimes that means that I don’t get my reviews back exactly on time- but better that than a crappy, half-thought-through review. I’m not sure that I always succeed. Sometimes I think that I may have missed points made by the authors, or I may have the wrong idea about an approach or result. However, if I’ve done a good job of trying to get it right the peer review process is working.
STAR WARS is really just a treatise on microbial evolution and the concept of the selfish gene. See below for more details.
So here’s the idea. The concept of midichlorians was introduced in the prequels. They are “a microscopic lifeform that reside within all living cells and communicate with the Force”. So essentially mitochondria, but powered by the Force. Han Solo has a great quote in episode IV,
Kid, I’ve flown from one side of this galaxy to the other, and I’ve seen a lot of strange stuff, but I’ve never seen *anything* to make me believe that there’s one all-powerful Force controlling everything. ‘Cause no mystical energy field controls *my* destiny. – Han Solo
But with midichlorians you now have a genetically discrete entity that is the sole communication with the powerful Force. The midichlorians want, in an evolutionary sense, to preserve and continue their lineage- they are ‘selfish’. So it stands to reason that they would have a say in what was going on with their hosts. A ‘host’ is simply a very large (relatively speaking) machine to enact the plans of the midichlorians. Of course. A kind of large biosuit for battle. So it’s amusing to think of them controlling all the battles like they’re playing video games.
Incidentally, this is not my first Star Wars inspired comic. That would be here.